The Magic Loop of Strategy

Sponsored by

In the field of strategy, there's a fascinating interplay between structured, data-driven planning and the seemingly more impulsive act of 'winging it.'

However, if someone claims their decisions are solely based on data and nothing else, they might be missing a significant part of the picture.

Strategy, especially in its most effective form, is not just a byproduct of data analysis. It's an intricate blend of data, intuition, and, sometimes, a bit of guesswork.

Admitting "I don’t know for sure" is not a sign of weakness; rather, it's an acknowledgment of the ever-present uncertainty in the field.

Uncertainty is a part of every strategy.

And I think we need to talk about what that exactly means.

Data against uncertainty?

In our quest for certainty, we often turn to data. The logic seems sound: the more data we have, the more informed our decisions will be.

We dive into competitor analysis, market research, customer surveys, and every measurable aspect of our business, from sign-ups and conversion rates to churn.

We even look at user behavior – what are they doing in our app, which pages are they visiting, and for how long? And let's not forget about search volume data – how many people are googling the problems we're trying to solve?

But there's a catch.

Even with mountains of data, there's often a lingering sense of insecurity about making strategic decisions.

Why?

Because data, as rich and informative as it is, cannot capture the full spectrum of human behavior and market dynamics. It gives us a snapshot but not the complete picture.

So, what's missing?

Data can tell us what's happening, but it can often fall short of explaining why it's happening or what we should do about it.

This is where human insight, intuition, and creativity come into play.

The most effective strategists combine data with a deep understanding of human behavior, market trends, and, sometimes, a gut feeling.

I've come to terms with the fact that strategy is not an exact science.

It's a mix of data, intuition, and educated guesses. And that's okay. The key is to use data as a guide, not a crutch, and to be comfortable making decisions with incomplete information.

It's about finding that sweet spot where data and intuition meet.

It’s not about always being right but about being less wrong more often. It's a continuous process of learning, adapting, and making the best decisions we can with the information we have. And sometimes, it involves a bit of 'winging it' – and that's a part of the strategy, too.

Now, let’s dig a bit deeper into that extra variable in the equation.

Strategy = Data + Magic

This equation encapsulates the essence of strategic planning, where data sets the stage, but magic — the creative leap — truly defines the outcome.

While data is invaluable in providing insights and guiding our decisions, it has its limits.

It can tell you where you are and where you've been, but it can't always tell you where to go. That decision, the choice of direction, necessitates a leap of faith, a creative spark that no amount of data can fully illuminate.

Shelly Bowen beautifully articulates this concept as 'the magic layer' of strategy. This magic layer signifies the creative, often intuitive leap that strategists must take.

It's about adding a human touch to the cold, hard facts.

Many of us, myself included, have sought a playbook, a step-by-step guide that guarantees success. But the reality is such a guide doesn't exist.

The strategy involves making educated guesses, formulating hypotheses, and sometimes, just going with your gut.

While these limitations are significant, many leading companies have found ways to overcome them. Let’s look at some case studies that exemplify the successful balance of data and intuition.

• Amazon's Product Development Strategy: Amazon's development of the Echo and Alexa is a prime example. While data indicated a growing interest in smart home devices, the creative leap involved developing a product that seamlessly integrated into daily life. Amazon's intuition about the potential of voice-activated technology, combined with customer behavior data, led to a highly successful product line.

• Starbucks' Store Location Strategy: Starbucks uses a sophisticated data-driven approach to determine new store locations. However, the final decision often incorporates human intuition and understanding local culture and habits. This blend of data and intuition has been pivotal in their global expansion.

• Spotify's Music Recommendation Algorithms: Spotify's algorithms suggest songs and playlists to users, but the company also understands the importance of human curation. Data provides insights into listening habits, but Spotify's editorial team adds a human touch by curating playlists that resonate on a more personal level, something algorithms can't fully replicate.

• Airbnb's Market Expansion Strategies: Airbnb's expansion into new markets is not just data-driven but also relies on understanding local cultures and traveler preferences. Their ability to intuitively grasp what makes a location attractive to travelers, combined with data on travel trends, has been key to their global success.

• Apple's Product Design Philosophy: Apple's product design, particularly for the iPhone and iPad, has always been a blend of Steve Jobs' intuitive understanding of what consumers desire and data on market trends and technological feasibility. This blend has led to groundbreaking products that defined entire categories.

These are only a handful of examples demonstrating how leading companies across various industries successfully combine data analysis with intuitive thinking to make strategic decisions, create innovative products, and launch impactful marketing campaigns.

The Human Element in Strategy

Strategy is profoundly human. It's shaped by the connections we forge, the understanding we develop through our experiences, and the unique perspectives we bring to the table.

Those experiences and perspectives allow us to interpret data in ways that machines cannot and see patterns that are not immediately obvious.

It is what turns data into insight and insight into action.

You might wonder how to apply this balance in your own professional context. Here are some actionable steps to merge data with intuition in your decision-making processes:

• Dedicated Brainstorming Sessions: Schedule regular brainstorming sessions where teams use data as a starting point for creative discussions. A marketing team might review customer engagement data and brainstorm campaign ideas aligning with observed trends. A retail company could use sales data to identify popular products and then brainstorm innovative marketing strategies or cross-promotion opportunities for these items.

• Cross-Functional Team Meetings: Encourage meetings between different departments (e.g., marketing, sales, product development) to discuss data findings and gather diverse perspectives. At Google, cross-functional meetings often lead to innovative product features, as engineers and marketers bring different viewpoints on user data.

• Customer Journey Mapping with Data Points: Create detailed customer journey maps incorporating data points at each stage. Use these maps to identify potential areas for improvement or innovation intuitively. E-commerce platforms often map customer journeys, using data from website analytics to redesign website layouts for a better, intuitive user experience.

• Encouraging Data-Driven Storytelling: Train team members to tell stories with data, turning numbers into narratives. This helps in making data more relatable and sparks creative thinking. Companies like Airbnb use data-driven storytelling to understand host and guest experiences, leading to intuitive enhancements in their platform.

• Implementing Regular Feedback Loops: Establish regular feedback loops where data is reviewed, and team members can contribute intuitive insights based on their experiences and expertise. Salesforce regularly reviews customer usage data and gathers feedback from the sales team to guide product development intuitively.

• Incorporating Design Thinking with Data Analysis: Adopt design thinking approaches, where empathy and human-centered design are combined with data analysis to solve problems creatively. IBM uses design thinking workshops where data on user behavior guides the design process, but final decisions often include intuitive judgments about user needs.

• Cultivating a Culture of Curiosity: Foster a workplace environment that values curiosity and encourages employees to ask 'what if' questions based on data insights. 3M, known for its innovative culture, encourages employees to explore new ideas by looking at data trends and asking questions that challenge the status quo.

By implementing these steps, professionals can merge data and intuition effectively in their decision-making processes, leading to more innovative and informed strategies and solutions.

Make (some of) it up

The concept of 'making it up as you go' in strategy and entrepreneurship is liberating and misunderstood.

It's a phrase that often surfaces in the narratives of successful entrepreneurs, leading to a common misconception: that these leaders are navigating their journey without a compass, relying solely on instinct and improvisation.

But that’s far away from the truth.

First off, it's important to clarify that when successful entrepreneurs talk about 'winging it,' they aren't referring to a chaotic, directionless process.

Instead, they're alluding to the 'magic layer' of strategy. This layer is where creativity meets data, where intuition intersects with empirical evidence.

In the startup world, a hypothesis-driven approach is fundamental.

Successful founders base their assumptions on experiments and data – these are their validated learnings. Think of the principles outlined in 'The Lean Startup': it's about building, measuring, learning, and then iterating.

However, these validated learnings don't eliminate the need for creativity. Instead, they provide a foundation for building creative and innovative strategies.

It’s like a loop where execution and data collection feed into each other. You execute a strategy, gather data from the results, and then use this new information to refine and adjust your approach.

It's a cycle of continuous improvement, where each iteration brings you closer to a more effective strategy.

In this context, making things up as you go means embracing the creative process within the confines of strategic planning. It's about trusting your instincts, using your insights, and applying your learning in innovative ways.

It's a dynamic process that acknowledges that while data can guide us, it cannot capture the full spectrum of possibilities that human creativity can explore.

In this process, the development of individual skills is crucial. Here are some exercises and practices that can help professionals enhance their intuitive skills, complementing their data analysis expertise:

• Reflective Journaling: Encourage professionals to maintain a journal where they record and reflect on their daily experiences, decisions, and outcomes. This practice helps recognize patterns in decision-making and understand intuition's role. A project manager could write about a key decision made during the day, noting the data involved and how intuition played a role. Over time, this can reveal insights into their intuitive strengths and areas for improvement.

• Scenario Planning: Regularly engage in scenario planning exercises where you envision various future scenarios based on current data and then rely on intuition to navigate these scenarios. Executives at a technology firm might imagine how emerging technologies could disrupt their market and intuitively plan strategic responses.

• Creative Problem-Solving Workshops: Organize workshops that focus on creative problem-solving techniques, such as design thinking, which encourage looking beyond the data to find innovative solutions. IDEO, a global design company, runs workshops that teach how to use design thinking to solve complex problems, balancing data with human-centered design and intuition.

• Intuition Practice Sessions: Set aside time for team members to practice and discuss intuitive decision-making. This could involve exercises like making quick decisions on minor issues without over-relying on data. A marketing team could practice this by quickly brainstorming campaign ideas without extensive market research, relying instead on their understanding of the brand and customer.

• Role-Playing Exercises: Role-playing different business scenarios can help in developing empathy and an intuitive understanding of customers, colleagues, and business partners. Customer service teams can role-play as customers with specific needs and complaints, helping to understand and address customer issues intuitively.

By incorporating these exercises and practices into their routine, professionals can enhance their intuitive skills, leading to a more balanced and effective approach to their decision-making processes.

Trying to be less wrong instead of being right

There's a pivotal shift in mindset that can make all the difference: moving from being right to being less wrong.

This subtle yet profound shift redefines how we approach the uncertainty inherent in strategy. When I first delved into the world of strategy, I was driven by a singular goal: to discover the 'right' way to do things.

This quest was fueled by a mix of necessity and a deep-seated impostor syndrome. I believed that somewhere in the depths of my studies, I would find a clear, unambiguous path to content strategy success.

This was not the case.

Despite immersing myself in qualitative and quantitative data, I was often left grappling with uncertainty. The realization eventually dawned on me that this uncertainty didn't indicate failure or inadequacy in my approach.

Rather, it was a fundamental characteristic of strategic planning.

The key was to embrace the unknown as just another constraint in the complex equation of strategy. It wasn't about eliminating uncertainty but learning to navigate it effectively.

This meant acknowledging that there might not be a single 'right' way to do things. Instead, there were multiple paths, each with its own set of trade-offs and potential outcomes.

Have a great week!

- Dimitris

💭 Say hi on Twitter/X